Kory,
First off, someone has given you bad information. Pine Canyon has 3 ponds, pond 1 is nearest the gate (USUALLY the best pond for non-stop catch & release, however seems like they've already entered lock jaw), pond 2 is the next one you'll stumble upon on the dirt road and fish are still pretty active (especially from a boat and just like Dustin described t-rig or shaky IN the reeds, top in morn and late evening), Pond 3 can be reached by going left at the Y near pond 2 and stay right at the campground (don't fish there much, but usually have pretty good luck from the dock and casting way out to the edge of the reeds). Punch Bowl is near the horse stables if you go out the Utah Gate (Housing) great pond when filled. Unfortunately, it's more like a swamp right now and not sure if it will ever come back to life.